Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Comparison (Review #3)


So. I have recently finished the book Delirium by Lauren Oliver. Unsatisfied is an understatement to how I feel. I have also read The Hunger Games  by Suzanne Collins a few years back and seeing as they are both dystopias, I may have gone into this new book with too high of expectations. Of course, it was only the first installment of the trilogy so I assume the story will grow more dramatic towards the end.

Let's compare Lena (female protagonist from Delirium) and Katniss (female protagonist from The Hunger Games). Their stories are set up in a very similar way. They both live in an oppressive world where the government keeps many secrets from its citizens and both Lena and Katniss are in the more impoverished area of their country. There are resisters who preside in the world outside of the main lands. They also are missing parts of their families and have little sisters that they care immensely about. It seems that a lot of their set up is the same. They have similar backgrounds and living environments but they go about their rebellion completely different from one another.

Where Katniss is a strong independent protagonist, Lena is a loving but timid one. They both are suspicious about their predicaments but Katniss catches on slightly faster (although that could have to do with being forced to kill other kids . . . maybe). The interesting thing is that they go through parallel internal conflicts. Katniss starts to become slightly more caring and loving to those around her where Lena becomes slightly stronger and more independent. This is an interesting and alternating way for the characters to develop. I would imagine that going through the emotions they have (extreme shock at learning that your whole life was a lie) would do that to a person. One would, perhaps, gravitate towards attributes that they didn’t have previously have in an attempt to adapt to their new environment. I look forward to continuing Lena’s journey in the next books and comparing them to Katniss’ own journey.

No comments:

Post a Comment